A US federal appeals court ruled 2-1 that the Department of Defense acted within its legal authority when it blacklisted Anthropic technology. The decision follows a legal battle sparked by Anthropic’s refusal to grant the military unrestricted access to certain Claude features, which led the federal government to ban defense contractors from doing business with the AI startup.
The DC Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Secretary of Defense had the legal standing to balance competing operational and safety risks under federal procurement law. While a California district court previously found the administration’s action unlawful under a separate supply-chain risk statute, the DC Circuit maintained exclusive jurisdiction over the procurement authority used for the designation.
Anthropic stated it respectfully disagrees with the ruling and is considering further legal options, including an en banc appeal or petitioning the Supreme Court. The legal conflict underscores growing regulatory friction between commercial AI safety guardrails and military procurement requirements.
Why it matters
Commercial AI vendors face severe government procurement bans if their safety policies restrict military deployment requests.
Conflicting federal court rulings create ongoing legal uncertainty around executive authority to penalize AI companies on national security grounds.
Source: arstechnica.com



