A U.S. federal judge has dismissed antitrust lawsuits brought by Chegg and Penske Media against Google over its AI-driven search features. The plaintiffs alleged that Google unlawfully scraped proprietary content to feed its Gemini models and generate AI Overviews, cannibalizing organic website traffic without compensating original creators or offering a functional opt-out mechanism.
U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta ruled that Google’s conduct does not violate antitrust law, explaining that publishers hold an expectation—rather than a binding legal agreement—that search engines will refer traffic in exchange for indexed content. While acknowledging the financial harm and challenges facing digital publishers, Mehta noted that courts cannot extend antitrust statutes to address economic disruption absent legislation.
While Google secured a legal victory in the U.S., the decision highlights a growing global divide in AI regulation. Legislative bodies and regulators in Europe and the UK continue to evaluate rules forcing search engines to provide AI opt-outs or compensate publishers directly for scraped content.
Why it matters
U.S. courts are refusing to use antitrust laws to protect online publishers from AI summary traffic losses.
Web creators face uncompensated content scraping for AI models unless legislative bodies enact new protections.
Regulatory approaches diverge, with Europe and the UK pursuing stricter controls and compensation requirements than the U.S.
Source: arstechnica.com



